I like #1 in that the 2nd player gets no pts if his opponent killed one of their frogs ON the opening move.
Option #3 would work as well. I appreciate that you have put thought in to this. Hopefully there will be enough discussion to make a change happen to make the game more fair
(hide) If you only look at some of the discussion boards on a regular basis you can add them to your favourite boards list by going to the Board page and clicking "Add to my favourite boards". (pauloaguia) (show all tips)