I thought the reasons were that (1) there would be too many homeruns and fans would grow bored, since you can hit a ball farther with an aluminum bat, and (2) that they were afraid too many pitchers would get injured from lightning fast come-backers. I like your point too.
(hide) If you want to play a game with an opponent of a similar level, you can define a required BKR range for a new game invitation. Then nobody with a BKR outside this range will be able to see/accept it. (Katechka) (show all tips)