BrainKing - Keskustelualueet (Tournaments)

Valvoja(t): MadMonkey

Tournaments

Please use this board to discuss Tournaments and Team Tournaments, ask questions and hopefully find the answers you are looking for. Personal attacks, arguing or baiting will not be tolerated on this board. If you have, or see a problem or something you are not happy about or think is wrong, please contact one of the above Moderators OR contact a Global Moderator HERE

Tournaments

Team Tournaments

May 2024 - Fevga 3 - starts 11th May

May 2024 - Nackgammon 4 - starts 25th May

June 2024 - Frog Finder 4 - starts 8th June

June 2024 - Plakoto 3 - starts 22 June

Lista keskustelualueista
Sinulla ei ole oikeutta kirjoittaa tälle alueelle. Tälle alueelle kirjoittamiseen vaadittu minimi jäsenyystaso on Brain-Sotilas.

Moodi: Kaikki voivat lähettää viestejä

29. Syyskuu 2006, 02:55:40

MadMonkey

näytä tämän käyttäjän viestit | Näytä keskustelusäie | linkki

It comes down to how you interprit how the rules are worded really. I would say both answers are correct, it was Nirvanas move, but as she could not go Furbster still had a LEGAL move.

29. Syyskuu 2006, 03:06:28

Nirvana

näytä tämän käyttäjän viestit | Näytä keskustelusäie | linkki

Otsikko: Re:

MadMonkey:
I didn't get the chance to pass it back to Furbster, the system was what declared it a draw. It was also the system which put me in the next round, and I really do think the game should have gone to Furbster.

29. Syyskuu 2006, 15:19:03

toedder

näytä tämän käyttäjän viestit | Näytä keskustelusäie | linkki

Otsikko: Re:

MadMonkey: No, I don't think this is a matter of interpretation. Let's quote the rules literally again:

How to finish the game

The game ends if one player cannot make a legal move.

In this game it was Nirvana's turn. She couldn't make a legal move. So ONE PLAYER could not make a legal move, and the game is over. There is no rule about "passing" a move. If it would be possible, the game would never be over until all the board was populated - as long as there is only one free square, there is always one legal move to be made. So in this case the rules would say:

How to finish the game

The game ends when all the board is covered.

29. Syyskuu 2006, 16:26:22

MadMonkey

näytä tämän käyttäjän viestit | Näytä keskustelusäie | linkki

Otsikko: Re:

Mr. Shumway: I agree with what you say, we have to play by what the rules are here on Brainking. The thing is depending where you have played it, as i have before the Rules are different.
Just an example from Gamerz.net:

'If you are unable to move on your turn, you are skipped. There is a chance that your opponent may be forced to make a move that will let you move again'

This is why its hard to implement games, you could play a game somewhere else and swear your rules are correct, when they only are for that site.