Brugernavn: Kodeord:
Ny bruger registrering
Moderator: SueQ , coan.net 
 Backgammon

Backgammon and variants.

Backgammon Links


Meddelelser per side:
Liste over diskussionsborde
Du har ikke rettigheder til at skrive meddelelser til dette bord, Mindste medlemsskabsniveau nødvendigt for at skrive til dette bord er BrainBonde.
Tilstand: Alle kan skrive
Søg i meddelelser:  

1. Maj 2010, 20:22:10
Thom27 
Emne: Re: Most games are begin with same rolling dice numbers..
pedestrian: This is well possible, I must only download more files. I'm working on it...

I'm also going to do a chi-square test, which calculates a probability for an event to occur by coincidence, under the assumption that the dice are ok (equally distributed and independent).

1. Maj 2010, 21:39:00
wetware 
Emne: Re: Most games are begin with same rolling dice numbers..
Tilpasset af wetware (1. Maj 2010, 21:47:11)
Thom27: I agree, and have spent an inordinate amount of time analyzing results here.  (I wish it were easier to do, or that the flaw was ALWAYS evident, or the underlying pattern easier to discern.)  I'll continue playing less and less here, until it's remedied.  (I want to spend more time playing and studying--not investigating an unusual system flaw.)  I'm generally an outspoken skeptic of various "dice cheating" claims, but what's happening here is too much of an outlier to be dismissed cavalierly.

I also tried (unsuccessfully) to identify WHEN this skewness began.  I hoped that by doing so, I might help the powers-that-be to identify some code or procedural change that might have triggered it.

2. Maj 2010, 14:36:34
moistfinger 
Emne: Re: Most games are begin with same rolling dice numbers..
wetware: The dice is a total joke on this website. It just doesn't feel right. I have never been one to whinge about backgammon dice before playing on Brainking. I know it is supposed to be random but it just isn't, it is skewed.

2. Maj 2010, 14:46:59
Pedro Martínez 
Emne: Re: Most games are begin with same rolling dice numbers..
moistfinger: However, it is quite surprising because BK uses a very sophisticated system to generate the dice. :)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7n8LNxGbZbs

2. Maj 2010, 15:33:43
grenv 
Emne: Re: Most games are begin with same rolling dice numbers..
Pedro Martínez: Great machine, and here was i thinking they paid 1000 people to sit at their cubes and roll dice!

If there is a defect it would seem not to be the random number generator but that the code doesn't use the generator in the particular case mentioned, but instead just gets the last number... sounds like a caching problem?
I wonder if those games were played with 2 people on the same computer? moves happening very quickly? We need more of this type of data most likely, in order to replicate the problem.

3. Maj 2010, 18:22:39
moistfinger 
Emne: Re: Most games are begin with same rolling dice numbers..
Pedro Martínez:
LOL

2. Maj 2010, 04:07:56
grenv 
Emne: Re: Most games are begin with same rolling dice numbers..
Thom27: That's a wierd bug... increasing the odds of the second roll equaling the first? What kind of twisted algorithm would cause that?..?..

Unless you wrote code that generated a random number first, then used that to determine whether to roll or just use the first result, ... but why write that sort of code?? It just doesn't seem like a plausible defect.

Any ideas?

Dato og klokkeslæt
Venner online
Favoritborde
Sammenslutninger
Dagens tip
Copyright © 2002 - 2024 Filip Rachunek, all rights reserved.
Tilbage til toppen