BrainKing - Tartışma Komiteleri (Espionage)

Moderatör: Chaos

Espionage

For all Espionage fans

Tartışma komitesi listesi
Bu komiteye yazı yazma izniniz yok. Bu komiteye yazabilmek için minimum üyelik seviyesi Brain Piyonu.

Durum: Herkes yazabilir

16. Eylül 2010, 03:56:25

Nothingness

bu kullanıcının mesajlarını göster | zinciri göster | Bağlantı

There is the option that we can have Fencer have them revealed when the 1st move is made. So that there is no honor system needed.

16. Eylül 2010, 12:32:42

SL-Mark

bu kullanıcının mesajlarını göster | zinciri göster | Bağlantı

Konu: Re:

Nothingness: There are some technicalities to that. For example, the player has to choose which recon they disclosed during negotiations. I would not want a program to determine this and show my 'tucked away' recon :)

In any event, whilst the idea is serious, I do not really think that it should be converted to a variant, there are far more worthy suggestions that have been put forward.

The idea was more about understanding the value information and its exchange.

Would you show me your five 1s and I'll show you where one of my 5s is located?

16. Eylül 2010, 14:56:56

Chaos

bu kullanıcının mesajlarını göster | zinciri göster | Bağlantı

Konu: Re:

SL-Mark: Would you show me your five 1s and I'll show you where one of my 5s is located?

I wouldn't. First because you know five of my pieces and I would only know one, but also because you know all of one sort: you know all of my 1s, so none of my other pieces can be a 1. I would only know one of your 5's, so I cannot conclude anything about the rest of your pieces.

16. Eylül 2010, 16:07:08

SL-Mark

bu kullanıcının mesajlarını göster | zinciri göster | Bağlantı

Konu: Re:

Chaos: So the value of five undisclosed 1s is greater than a disclosed 5

Okay, would you show me all your 1s for both of my 5s? A possible bargain here