Nume utilizator: Parolã:
Înregistrare utilizator nou
Moderator: SueQ , coan.net 
 Backgammon

Backgammon and variants.

Backgammon Links


Mesaje pe paginã:
Lista posturilor afişate
Nu eşti autorizat sã scrii pe acest panou.Pentru a putea adãuga mesaje trebuie sã ai nivelul de (0)
Mod: Toatã lumea poate afişa
Cautã între posturi:  

21. Aprilie 2003, 06:05:42
Kevin 
You know, i don't appreciate being told to shut up, even if it is sugar coated.

The thing that is not so good about that comparison is that placing one piece at a time in Pente is THE WHOLE GAME, while this rule in Backgammon is to say the least not very common. And the other thing about this backgammon rule is that it restricts what would otherwise be legal moves - only in those specific situations is it illegal, why?

21. Aprilie 2003, 06:11:55
rod03801 
Subiectul: Re:
No.. the moves ARE NOT legal. And it isnt rare just because YOU say it's rare. They are not legal because the rule IS: if you CAN use both dice, you MUST. Regardless of whether you like it or not.

21. Aprilie 2003, 06:54:58
ellieoop 
Subiectul: Re:
i'm in a game right now, where i could have done it, but didn't, to me it would be cheating, and i probably could have assured myself a win, now i'm wide open, but that's the game, i certainly couldn't play any gammon games with you kevin.

21. Aprilie 2003, 10:27:32
RsBaby 
Subiectul: Re:
Well lets look at chess shall we? Why does a knight move in a 2-1 "L" shape? Why not a 3-1 "L" shape? That certainly isn't "The whole game" as you put it. Now suppose here you could move your knight 3-1 as well as 2-1, would you say well it sometimes suits me to be able to do that so it's ok or would you instead pass a comment that the game wasn't being played to the rules? It is the same with backgammon. You keep asking why that is the rule. The answer to that is that if you understand the die roll possibilities and you understand that this rule applies then it is paramount as to how you move prior to the situation arising to avoid leaving yourself where having to play both dice will hurt you. Similarly you can create situations by using a backgammon tactic known as killing numbers to place your opponent in that same situation. You say it is not common, well it certainly isn't rare but what is common, though you may not realise it, is that many moves are made with the idea in mind of creating that situation, though not all will ever materialise.

To finish I would just like to deal with your comment "It would be fine if every piece could move like that through the whole game, although it wouldn't be chess." That is exactly the point, it may be fine although what we are playing certainly isn't backgammon. Having said that, without a cube in use which is far more fundamental to the game, then even if this is corrected what you are playing certainly isn't backgammon either, as cube action accounts for over 50% of the skill at the game. Regard it as a practice game for the real thing but even if you can play well here don't fool yourself you know how to play backgammon as when/if you do ever play the real game you will soon find out how little of the game you do actually understand.

21. Aprilie 2003, 19:27:44
rod03801 
Subiectul: Re:
EXCELLENTLY put, RsBaby!!! I was hoping someone better at putting it in words would comment.

21. Aprilie 2003, 20:22:25
Spencer 
Subiectul: Re:
Very well said, any other way of playing gammon would be cheating...

Data şi ora
Prieteni în direct
Jocurile favorite
Frãţiile
Ştirea zilei
Drept de copiere © 2002 - 2024 Filip Rachunek, toate drepturile rezervate.
Înapoi la Început de paginã