I like #1 in that the 2nd player gets no pts if his opponent killed one of their frogs ON the opening move.
Option #3 would work as well. I appreciate that you have put thought in to this. Hopefully there will be enough discussion to make a change happen to make the game more fair
(hide) If you click on a person's name and then click Finished games you will have a list of games that have been completed, then click on the name of the game to get a summary of all of these games, then click on the name of the game again and you will have a game to view and analyze. (Servant) (show all tips)