BrainKing - Tartışma Komiteleri (Feature requests)

Moderatör: rod03801

Feature requests

Do you miss something on BrainKing.com and would you like to see it here? Post your request into this board!
If there is a more specific board for the request, (i.e. game rule changes etc) then it should be posted and discussed on that specific board.

For further information about Feature Requests, please visit this link on the Brainking.Info site : http://brainking.info/archives/20-About-feature-requests.html

Tartışma komitesi listesi
Bu komiteye yazı yazma izniniz yok. Bu komiteye yazabilmek için minimum üyelik seviyesi Brain Piyonu.

Durum: Herkes yazabilir

5. Aralık 2011, 09:02:37

pgt

bu kullanıcının mesajlarını göster | zinciri göster | Bağlantı

Konu: Ratings

I inadvertently checked "include unrated players" on a recent game invitation. While I'm happy to play against unrated players, I thought it was bloody ridiculous to see that I will get 0 points for a win, -12 for a draw, and -24 for a loss. How on earth are unrated players meant to get to play against rated players. How about setting up some sort of rating system which is fair to players with an established rating, and which also gives new players an opportunity to move up the ratings reasonably quickly to reach their level,

I might even be prepared to accept 0 points for a loss in a game of skill, but in games like backgammon, which is maybe 70% skill and 30 % luck (I bet that gets some reaction) it seems a bit silly to award zero points for a win - why would anybody interested in ratings ever play against an unrated player?

6. Aralık 2011, 08:30:44

Thad

bu kullanıcının mesajlarını göster | zinciri göster | Bağlantı

Konu: Re: Ratings

pgt: If you're rated 400 (I think it's 400) BKR above an opponent, you'll gain zero points in a win, but lose plenty in a loss. Unrated players basically have a 'hidden' rating that starts at 1600. So if your rating is high enough, it doesn't make sense to play unrated players, but if your rating isn't that high, then playing against unrated players is fine.

6. Aralık 2011, 10:30:39

pgt

bu kullanıcının mesajlarını göster | zinciri göster | Bağlantı

Konu: Re: Ratings

Thad: Exactly!

6. Aralık 2011, 14:22:44

Aganju

bu kullanıcının mesajlarını göster | zinciri göster | Bağlantı

Konu: Re: Ratings

Thad: I think the unrated starting point is 1300, not 1600.
You can see your 'unrated' rating under Statistics/Top Players/choose the game, at the very end of the page your rating is always shown.

6. Aralık 2011, 16:12:41

rod03801

bu kullanıcının mesajlarını göster | zinciri göster | Bağlantı

Konu: Re: Ratings

Aganju: 1300 is correct

6. Aralık 2011, 20:41:05

Thad

bu kullanıcının mesajlarını göster | zinciri göster | Bağlantı

Konu: Re: Ratings

1300. I wasn't sure about that number.

I think the real problem for pgt and others including me is that the BRK formula which works fine for chess does not work well for other games. I wish there were different formulae for different games based on their skill vs luck factor and other factors. Or is there a better one-size-fits-all formula that could be used?