I asked Fencer for new game - Pro gomoku (just 5 in line, pro rules).

:-) just discussions coz we cant change anything. But I think 6 not win is more better coz a game will be more complicated and...

I think it should be changed, you're really only supposed to place 5 pieces. In fact, as many players know who play at other sites, one of a players DEFENSES is to force a sixth piece placement, since it is not a win.On the other hand, i believe i have only won a handful of games w/ 6 pieces, it doesn't really happen all that often.

five in line is different from six in line, and different from five or more in line too, so dont look at the name of game, I'm just sayin' about the rules

If you notice, it isn't go-moku...it's Five in Line...

the moku rules so strange, more than 5 stones can win too, never seen it before! that was so lucky that I took a look at these rules, lolz...

after initial 4 games you get provisional BKR rating then after 25 games you have an established BKR rating... .. and thanks... :)

oh thanks lovelysharon, you are lovely :-), but what they consider then ?that am I a provisional player to rate me or what?

you need to finish at least 4 games for a rating.. and then it is still considered provisional until you finish 25 ....

hi all, anyone know this: I finished and won 2 games, why my rating doesn't appear ? ( as you see, SonAnh still unrated )

About the colors (I agree with you, I prefer black & white myself, for the same reasons)
Go to Settings. Click on Five In Line. There, you'll see two rows, first small, the one under is bigger. Each row has two choices, it's hard to see but possible. First circle is a click box, then the two 'stones' (x & o), then another circle, white dot and black dot. So, you click in the FOURTH thingy.. LOL Does that make sense? ;)

Hi.

According to the rules of go-moku, over-lines (6 or more in a row) do not count. But this is not official go-moku here...yet :-)

it does not give you a win in Its Your Turn!!

See, I told you :op LOL 6 in a roll does win, it only makes sence, if five wins it, one more can't hurt LOL

ok ... I just lost a game ... 6 in a row does win here !

Yes, I understand that, all I'm saying is I've never had trouble winning with 6 in-a-roll and yes it is alot easier to win in the very beginning of the game than it is in the middle or at the end. If the game goes on too long, its harder to win and the game drags on, but I guess thats what you get for not winning in the first place. LOL

Well:
"When the players got stronger they found that playing with "completely free" rules was in great favour of Black (the beginner of the game). It is also proved that there is a sure win for Black when playing with "completely free" rules."
(from http://www.renju.nu/r1rulhis.htm)
The rule "no-more-then-five for black" is one of "black" restrictions in renju.

I've never had trouble winning with 6 in a roll:o)

Hi,
5inLine is based on gomoku/renju games, and there is standard "black begins" in these games. Is it a big problem to set black color for the player whith the first move?

Based on the rule here, it says "5 or more" ... I am in a game right now that the opponent has a chance to place 6 in a row ... but he/she hasn't do it yet ...

does 6 in a row really give you a win?

Based on the rule, you can still win with 6 in a row ... at IYT you're not ... ????

Try it now.

I have done that Fencer but all I get are the X and O pattern.

WJW: Go to your Settings / Five in Line page and select the second set.

The board at IYT is much easier on the eyes...There you play on the lines, here you play in the square. The color is ok, It's how you play @ IYT the marbles look like marbles they stand out.. Here they look like black and white circles...

I dunno Pekka; I can't see how to do that. (what else is new)

Bill, you can already make that change in your settings. No need to play with X and 0.

I find the white stones for white and the black stones for black to be the best. When the pieces differ by colour and not by shape I find it much easier to grasp the position, especially when the games go beyond 20 moves and the board becomes increasingly crowded.

And what colors would be better?

I s there any chance of implementing a board using different coloured pieces for black and white? My eyes aren't the greatest and I find it very difficult to use this setup. The board and piece setup used by IYT is much less stressful for me. How do others feel about this?

Bill

Fencer has discussed implementing more tournament formats, including this one, sometime soon in the future. The one that is in place now is just the first one he has done :-)

Fencer: The game is better when played on a 15x15 board than a 13x13.
About the tournaments: If I`ve understood it correctly, only 1 game is played against each of the other players in the section, and is random who gets to play as white and make the first move. I don`t know about other games but in 5-in-line that doesn`t work because the white has a really huge advantage. In fact, with optimal gameplay (on a 15x15 board or bigger) the one making the first move should win every time.
Of course none of us plays perfect all the time, but still the advantage is too big when 2 really good players are against each other. This problem would be solved if tournament games were 2-game matches, one of each color. Like at IYT.

I hope that NTL user will be able to play this game. If not, I can make it 13x13.

thank you fencer for the 15x15 board.

13x13 at IYT rarely fills and 15x15 pro version is even rarer...i've personally never seen it happen....so 15x15 would be a good size...20x20 is more of a "Go" size.

15X15 sounds great to me fencer.

now I remember Gold token..senile moment, I guess..thanks

GT is Goldtoken:
http://www.goldtoken.com/
:-)

what and where is GT games?

I've tried all of that, nothing helps

What about the size option in new game?

Is anyone having trouble with the 5 in a line game having two different size grids? Part of mine are square and the other half is rectangular.

for regular go-moku (which this is essentially the same) i have never played on a board bigger than 13x13. They use that at IYT...i have played approximately 200 games of that and 2 of them have filled up, both agaginst the same person (lol). 15x15 would certainly be big enough though imo!

Would 15x15 be acceptable?

Have you ever installed the smaller boards for this game..? (five in line) I too have an old Classic WebTv and YES, with smaller boards, classic webbers shouldn't have any problem with playing this game and I really WOULD like to play.. Besides, I have never seen anyone fill up a board of that size.. People I've talked to say the same thing........... A~n~y~w~a~y.....
Have you or will you make smaller boards..? PLEASE!!!!

KATHYR, two ways you can do that.. 1st, if you haven't played any or only a couple times, you can just DELETE it or ask your opponent to DELETE it fore you and just explain your reason.. 2nd, you can just let TIME run out for you to take your turn and it should DELETE itself.. (hope you don't have a lot of days put on it.. lol) If you have played more than a couple turns apiece on it, someone will lose the game instead of just being DELETED where no one wins or loses.. :-))

i DIDNOT ask to play five in line becouse my web unit will not give me a full screen for that game. I WANT TO BE REMOVED FROM THAT GAME. PLEASE!

i do get upgrades, i think it's the old classics that have the problems, my husband is on web also, and his is newer, my husband got page too big on a disney pin site, that's the only time. i guess we are lucky. i play at gt. and iyt and they're fine.
ellie.