User Name: Password:
New User Registration
Moderator: Fencer 
 Knight Fight

Discuss about the Knight Fight game or find new opponents.


Messages per page:
List of discussion boards
You are not allowed to post messages to this board. Minimum level of membership required for posting on this board is Brain Pawn.
Mode: Everyone can post
Search in posts:  

8. March 2008, 19:23:12
ScorpionOct64 
Subject: repeat
i just started 3 games with diffrent people and the numbers were the same...i thought it was random ...just wonder if its just chance or some bug in system...

8. March 2008, 19:29:35
MadMonkey 
Subject: Re: repeat
ScorpionOct64: Did you set them all at the same time ?

It does seem to do this, even worse in Tournaments, as if you have one bad board, all of them are bad. I think all games of Knight Fight should be totally random myself.

I started a Tournament, and had all 90's+ numbers at the opposite end of the board. Of course, it was the same for every game and can work as a BIG disadvantage

8. March 2008, 19:34:53
ScorpionOct64 
Subject: Re: repeat
MadMonkey: i think all 3 were in same tourny....if i win one then i win all but if not...ty for your reply ...i was just surprised sinice i had to make all 3 opening moves the same

8. March 2008, 20:42:16
TheFadingX 
Subject: Re: repeat
ScorpionOct64:

We're in the same tourney, and all 6 games have the exact same board. I honestly think this should be categorized as a bug, cause all the games should be random.

8. March 2008, 20:45:22
Fencer 
Subject: Re: repeat
TheFadingX: Why?

8. March 2008, 21:01:04
TheFadingX 
Subject: Re: repeat
Fencer: Why it's a bug? Because according to the rules of the game state that "100 squares are assigned, in a randomly fashion", having 6 games end up exact copies of themselves is statistically improbable. Hence the bug where only one game is randomly generated and copied 6 times.

8. March 2008, 21:03:17
MadMonkey 
Subject: Re: repeat
TheFadingX: And certainly not fair in Tournaments

I like our idea of a Dark version, with bonus squares (though i would mention that while i was here lol)

8. March 2008, 21:03:38
Fencer 
Subject: Re: repeat
TheFadingX: It's a problem of the respective tournament creator who defined the tournament with same starting positions for all games. Not a game bug.

8. March 2008, 21:17:45
TheFadingX 
Subject: Re: repeat
Fencer: I was not aware of that, haven't read the tourney info before joining.

coan.net: Perhaps it's fair if it's a 2 games per match, but that's not the case in the tourney I'm in.

8. March 2008, 21:21:12
coan.net 
Subject: Re: repeat
TheFadingX: Well then the tournament creator should have chosen to have different setups for each person instead of the same - if they were not having a 2 game per match.

(I believe that is an option you can also see before you sign up for a tournament for things to look at on other tournaments you might join)

8. March 2008, 21:24:06
TheFadingX 
Subject: Re: repeat
coan.net: Yes. As I already mentioned I haven't read the information before joining. I have been mistaken thinking that was a bug.

8. March 2008, 21:42:26
joshi tm 
Subject: Re: repeat
Fencer: The only games that override thatsetting are Frog Finder/Legs games?

9. March 2008, 09:08:14
Fencer 
Subject: Re: repeat
joshi tm: Yes.

11. March 2008, 14:53:50
Czuch 
Subject: Re: repeat
joshi tm: I agree, a random game set up should not be allowed to have the option to start with the same set up in different games....

I also agree with BBW, that if the same two players are playing a two game match, they should be allowed to be set up with the same board and each gets to play the other position.

I think the problem, Fencer, if there is one, is that the rules are stated incorrectly, they should say that all games are set up random, with the exception of certain tournaments....

as it is now, I have to agree with Fanding, the rules say all games are set up random, and there is no indication in the tournament description that they are set up the same, so something is not correct, and it should be rectified, please.

Date and time
Friends online
Favourite boards
Fellowships
Tip of the day
Copyright © 2002 - 2024 Filip Rachunek, all rights reserved.
Back to the top